The impact of CBT and ACT models using psychology trainee therapists - A preliminary controlled effectiveness trial

No Thumbnail Available

Authors

Lappalainen, Raimo
Lehtonen, Tuula
Skarp, Eerika
Taubert, Eija
Ojanen, Markku
Hayes, Steven C.

Issue Date

2007

Type

Citation

Language

Keywords

acceptance , acceptance and commitment therapy , cognitive behavior therapy , processes of change , therapist training

Research Projects

Organizational Units

Journal Issue

Alternative Title

Abstract

The present study compares the impact of individualized treatment provided by trainee therapists based on a traditional cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) and acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) model. Fourteen therapists were given initial training in CBT and ACT. Outpatients (N = 28) were randomized to either approach, with each therapist treating one client within each model, linked to a functional analysis. Clients treated within an ACT model showed better symptom improvement than the CBT clients, despite the fact that students felt initially less knowledgeable about ACT and were more fearful throughout when it was used. CBT improved client self-confidence more rapidly than ACT, and ACT improved acceptance more than CBT. Both processes predicted better outcomes; acceptance remained predictive when controlling for self-confidence but not vice versa. Overall, therapists with limited training in both models got better results with ACT and the processes of change fit with the ACT model.

Description

Citation

Publisher

License

In Copyright

Journal

Volume

Issue

PubMed ID

ISSN

0145-4455

EISSN

Collections